Review Guidelines
The EPH International Journal of Mathematics and Statistics is committed to a fair, confidential, and constructive peer-review process. Reviewers play an essential role in assessing the originality, academic quality, methodological soundness, and research integrity of submitted manuscripts.
Reviewers are expected to provide independent, objective, and evidence-based assessments that support editorial decisions and help authors improve their research.
Purpose of Peer Review
Peer review ensures that submitted manuscripts meet the journal's academic and publication standards. Reviewers should assess whether manuscripts:
- Demonstrate originality and contribute meaningfully to mathematics, statistics, or related disciplines.
- Present clear research objectives and an appropriate theoretical or analytical framework.
- Use sound mathematical, statistical, and research methods.
- Provide valid results and logically supported conclusions.
- Follow recognised standards of research integrity and publication ethics.
Assessments should be based on academic merit and subject expertise, without personal bias or irrelevant considerations.
Peer Review Process and Standards
Manuscripts that pass the initial editorial screening may be assigned to independent reviewers with relevant subject expertise. Reviewers evaluate scholarly quality and suitability for publication, while the editorial team considers their recommendations when making publication decisions.
- Reviewers are selected according to their academic qualifications, research experience, and subject expertise.
- Manuscripts are assessed independently and impartially.
- Reviewer identities and manuscript information must remain confidential.
- The editorial team retains responsibility for the final publication decision.
The journal aims to ensure fair evaluation without discrimination based on nationality, institutional affiliation, gender, personal beliefs, or other irrelevant factors.
Reviewer Responsibilities
Reviewers are expected to uphold professional and ethical standards throughout the evaluation process. Their responsibilities include:
1. Maintain Confidentiality
Manuscripts, supplementary materials, research data, and review communications must remain confidential. Unpublished content must not be shared or used for personal or professional advantage.
2. Provide Objective and Constructive Feedback
Reviews should be impartial, respectful, and evidence-based, focusing on the academic quality of the research rather than the personal or institutional background of the authors.
3. Assess Academic and Technical Quality
Reviewers should examine the theoretical framework, mathematical reasoning, statistical methods, research methodology, analytical accuracy, and interpretation of results, as applicable.
4. Declare Conflicts of Interest
Any financial, professional, institutional, academic, or personal relationship that may affect impartiality must be disclosed. Reviewers should decline the invitation if a conflict cannot be appropriately managed.
5. Identify Ethical Concerns
Reviewers should report suspected plagiarism, duplicate publication, data fabrication, falsification, inappropriate authorship, citation manipulation, or other potential research misconduct to the editorial office.
6. Adhere to Review Timelines
Reviewers should complete assessments within the agreed timeframe and promptly inform the editorial office if additional time is required or they cannot undertake the review.
Conflict of Interest and Reviewer Independence
Reviewers must maintain independence and impartiality. Any relationship or circumstance that could influence their assessment must be disclosed to the editorial office before proceeding. Potential conflicts may include:
- Recent or ongoing research collaboration with the authors.
- Institutional or professional relationships that may affect impartiality.
- Financial interests, funding arrangements, or commercial relationships related to the research.
- Personal relationships or professional disputes that may influence judgement.
- Direct academic or professional competition that could affect the evaluation.
The editorial team will determine the appropriate course of action after considering any disclosed conflict of interest.
Manuscript Evaluation Criteria
Reviewers should assess each manuscript in relation to its subject area, research objectives, and intended scholarly contribution. The evaluation should consider:
Originality and Novelty
Whether the manuscript presents original research, new theoretical insights, mathematical developments, statistical approaches, or meaningful extensions of existing knowledge.
Theoretical and Methodological Rigour
The suitability of the theoretical framework, research design, mathematical models, statistical methods, assumptions, and analytical procedures.
Mathematical and Statistical Accuracy
The correctness of mathematical derivations, equations, statistical calculations, algorithms, numerical results, and interpretations, where applicable.
Relevance and Scholarly Contribution
Whether the research addresses a relevant academic problem and contributes meaningfully to mathematics, statistics, or associated disciplines.
Validity of Results and Conclusions
Whether the findings are supported by the analysis, conclusions follow logically from the results, and research limitations are acknowledged.
Literature Review and References
The relevance, accuracy, and adequacy of cited literature, including the use of appropriate scholarly sources and balanced referencing practices.
Clarity and Organisation
The logical structure, clarity of explanations, consistency of terminology, presentation of equations, and overall quality of scholarly communication.
Ethical Compliance and Research Integrity
Reviewers should remain alert to potential ethical concerns and research misconduct. Any concerns must be reported confidentially to the editorial office with relevant explanations or supporting observations. These may include:
- Plagiarism, substantial textual similarity, or unattributed use of published material.
- Duplicate, redundant, or fragmented publication.
- Fabrication, falsification, or inappropriate manipulation of research data, mathematical results, tables, or figures.
- Inappropriate authorship attribution or undisclosed contributions.
- Citation manipulation or other unethical referencing practices.
- Missing ethical approvals, permissions, or conflict-of-interest disclosures, where applicable.
Reviewers should not directly confront authors about suspected misconduct. Such concerns should be referred to the editorial team for assessment under the journal's publication ethics policies.
Responsible Use of Artificial Intelligence
Reviewers must protect the confidentiality and intellectual property of submitted manuscripts. Unpublished manuscripts, research data, figures, and other confidential materials must not be uploaded to publicly accessible AI platforms or third-party services that may retain or disclose the content.
Reviewers remain responsible for the accuracy and integrity of their evaluations. Any permitted use of AI-assisted tools must not compromise confidentiality, introduce unsupported assessments, or replace independent academic judgement.
Structure of the Review Report
Review reports should be clear, structured, and sufficiently detailed to help authors address concerns and assist editors in making informed decisions. Reports may include:
- Summary of the Manuscript: A brief overview of the research objectives, methods, and principal contributions.
- Major Comments: Substantial concerns relating to originality, methodology, mathematical or statistical accuracy, interpretation, and research contribution.
- Minor Comments: Suggestions concerning clarity, terminology, formatting, references, and presentation.
- Recommendation: A publication recommendation supported by clear academic reasoning.
Reviewers should distinguish essential corrections affecting research validity from minor suggestions intended to improve presentation.
Review Recommendations and Editorial Decisions
Reviewers should provide one of the following recommendations based on the manuscript's academic merit and the extent of any required revisions:
Accept
The manuscript meets the journal's scholarly and publication requirements and requires no substantial further revision.
Minor Revision
The manuscript is generally suitable for publication but requires limited corrections or clarifications.
Major Revision
The manuscript requires substantial improvements to its methodology, theoretical development, analysis, interpretation, or presentation before reconsideration.
Reject
The manuscript does not meet the journal's requirements for originality, academic quality, methodological validity, relevance, or research integrity.
Reviewer recommendations are advisory. The final editorial decision rests with the Editor-in-Chief or authorised editorial representatives, taking into account the reviewer reports and the journal's standards.
Professional Conduct and Review Timelines
Reviewers should maintain professional conduct and communicate respectfully with the editorial office. Reviews should be submitted within the agreed timeframe to support an efficient editorial process. Reviewers are expected to:
- Accept invitations only when the manuscript falls within their expertise and sufficient time is available.
- Inform the editorial office promptly if they cannot complete a review within the agreed timeframe.
- Request extensions in advance and explain any anticipated delays.
- Maintain respectful and professional communication throughout the review process.
Publication Ethics and COPE Guidelines
The journal expects reviewers to follow recognised standards of publication ethics and responsible peer review. Reviewers should refer to the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) guidelines for peer reviewers.
Reviewers must uphold confidentiality, impartiality, transparency, and academic integrity. Concerns regarding ethical violations or inappropriate conduct should be reported to the editorial office for appropriate consideration under the journal's policies.
Commitment to Scholarly Excellence
The EPH International Journal of Mathematics and Statistics recognises reviewers as essential contributors to scholarly publishing. Through independent evaluation, constructive feedback, and adherence to ethical responsibilities, reviewers help strengthen research quality, maintain academic credibility, and advance knowledge in mathematics and statistics.